Skip to main content
added 6 characters in body
Source Link
Alexandre Eremenko
  • 51.1k
  • 3
  • 84
  • 187

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, crediting Copernicus has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given some credit, though his work did not survive and we know almost nothing about it. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he haddeveloped a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, crediting Copernicus has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given some credit, though his work did not survive and we know almost nothing about it. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he had a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, crediting Copernicus has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given some credit, though his work did not survive and we know almost nothing about it. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he developed a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)

added 16 characters in body
Source Link
Alexandre Eremenko
  • 51.1k
  • 3
  • 84
  • 187

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, thiscrediting Copernicus has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given some credit, though his work did not survive and we know almost nothing about it. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he had a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, this has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given credit, though his work did not survive. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he had a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, crediting Copernicus has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given some credit, though his work did not survive and we know almost nothing about it. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he had a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)

Source Link
Alexandre Eremenko
  • 51.1k
  • 3
  • 84
  • 187

There is an evidence that heliocentrism was proposed by some ancient Greek philosophers, in particular Aristarchus of Samos. His work did not survive, and all we know about it is a brief mentioning in one work of Archimedes.

Concerning Ibn al-Haytham, Wikipedia mentions his works where he criticized Ptolemy, but does not mention that he ever advocated heliocentrism. If you have a source which says this, please give a reference.

It is highly unlikely that Copernicus could read Ibn al-Haytham. (I doubt that he could read Arabic and that al-Haytham was translated into Latin). But Copernicus mentions his ancient Greek predecessors.

Concerning "giving credit" this is a question of opinion. On my opinion, this has nothing to do with "eurocentrism". (Aristarchus was also a European, and he is given credit, though his work did not survive. About al-Haytham, I have never heard that he had a heliocentric system. Please give a source if you know one.)