3
$\begingroup$

Sean Carroll, while speaking about the history of quantum field theory, has said a couple of times (without being completely sure of its factuality) that Richard Feynman was motivated by his trying to solve the cosmological constant problem.

Here is an excerpt from a recent Mindscape episode, The Crisis in Physics:

That's the vacuum energy. They're the same thing. Okay, just different languages used to describe the same idea, the difference is that long after Einstein, by the '50s and '60s, people realize there could be different contributions to the cosmological constant. So in fact, Feynman I think I understand this correctly, but it's not a common fact, so maybe I'm hallucinating a little bit. One of Feynman's motivations for inventing Feynman diagrams was to get rid of quantum field theory. Back in the '50s, you could be ambitious like that, right now, quantum field theory works too well, it's a harder ambition to have, but in the 1950s, you could have said, Well, maybe I can get all the benefit of quantum field theory without all the downsides, like the infinites and one of the things that he knew was a problem Feynman was that if you have a field that fills all of empty space, even if there's no particles, even if it's in the lowest energy state in the vacuum state, it can still have energy.

From a previous episode, Tim Maudlin on Locality, Hidden Variables, and Quantum Foundations

I don't know if you know this, 'cause I only recently learned it, but Richard Feynman, when he was inventing Feynman diagrams, part of his motivation was to get rid of quantum field theory and replace it with another theory, particles again, and we now think of Feynman diagrams is a tool for understanding quantum field theory, so he changed his mind, but his motivation, I'm told, was the cosmological constant problem.

I could not find any confirmation about this, even if there are plenty of quotes of Feynman on the cosmological constant problem. Was something that Feynman said himself?

$\endgroup$
0

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

The first Feynman diagram in print appeared in Fig 1 , p 772 of "Space-Time Approach to Quantum Electrodynamics", R P Feynman, Phys Rev 76 (1949) 769 – 789, published 15 September 1949, not a QFT paper, and without direct reference to the cosmological constant.

It was F Dyson, subsequently that same year, who connected Feynman diagrams to the QFT we know and use today.

I'm not sure I understand the quotes and the question to answer it, but even in his work on gravitation, e.g. his 1960s lectures on it, RPF did not appear to be intrigued by the cosmological constant problem as appreciated today. S Weinberg focussed the community on it decades later.

Of course, Feynman being the visual type (I was his TA in 1976), used all types of Feynman-like diagrams in his lectures before or after that; he called them "funny diagrams", and had a special type of harsh derision for experimentalists starting their talks with them, as a special type of voodoo-incantation... A nice discussion of their spread is in Ari Gross, "Pictures and pedagogy: The role of diagrams in Feynman's early lectures", Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 43 (3) (2012) pp 184-194.

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for the sources. You confirm my intuition. If you do not mind, I will leave the question unaccepted for a while $\endgroup$
    – Mauricio
    Aug 6, 2023 at 18:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.