More specifically, was Newton aware that given an inverse pair of functions $f$ and $h$ such that

$$f(h(x)) = x = h(f(x))$$ about the origin that, for

$$(x,y)=(h(y),f(x)),$$

the derivatives satisfy

$$f^{'}(x) = 1/h^{'}(y)$$

or

$$dy/dx = 1/(dx/dy)$$

near the origin?

Heuristically, this follows symbolically from

$$dy = f^{'}(x)dx = f^{'}(x)h^{'}(y)dy. $$

And it follows geometrically for a function whose graph lies in the first quadrant by reflection through the bisector of the first quadrant, the line $y=x$. Clearly, the slope for any tangent line is inverted by the reflection just as displacements along the $x-$axis and the $y-$axis are interchanged. d. In fact, it follows directly from the tangent line perspective since $$ y = m \; x + b$$ and $$y = \frac{1}{m}(x-b)$$ describe an inverse pair.

Surely, with Newton's mastery of geometric calculus, he was aware of these relationships. Is there evidence of this in Newton's work?

Related MO-Q by Ziegler.

Cross-posted from this MO-Q and an identical question on MSE.

Edit 6/12/17:

An example of a calculation incorporating the IFT that would have been obvious to Newton and plausible for him to have performed if only as a simple check of his general formulas:

It was known well before Newton that

$$\frac{d\tan(x)}{dx} = 1+ \tan^2(x),$$

or, with $y = \tan(x)$,

$$\frac{dy}{dx} = 1+ y^2.$$

In terms of fluxions and fluents, this could be put in the form of Newton's implicit function

$$g(x,y,\dot{x},\dot{y})=\dot{y}-(1+y^2)\dot{x}=0.$$

Then

$$\frac{\dot{x}}{\dot{y}}= \frac{1}{1+y^2}=\frac{dx}{dy}, $$

and application of the binomial theorem and integration would give the series

$$ \arctan(y) = x = y - \frac{y^3}3+\frac{y^5}5-\frac{y^7}7+\dots. \tag3 $$

Newton could then have derived a series expression for $\tan(x)$ using his series reversion formula (see Ferraro) for finding the series for the compositional inverse of a function from its power series. In fact, the same procedure is applied to finding a series for $\sin(x)$ in Ferraro on pages 76-78 following an alleged reconstruction by Horsley of Newton's derivation of the series.

  • The comments to the identical MSE and MO questions provide related references. – Tom Copeland Jun 12 '17 at 23:52

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.