0
$\begingroup$

Who chose the term "model" in model theory?

What was their reason for choosing the word "model" to mean what it means now in model theory? The current meaning: "[interpretation] I is a model of [sentence] S" means "interpretation I happens to make [sentence] S state something true" (Wilfrid Hodges on SEP). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/model-theory/

In everyday English, "X models Y" means "X is a simplification of Y", but the "model" in model theory doesn't seem to come from that.

$\endgroup$
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ To me, the meaning model in model theory is quite similar to the oldest meanings of model in English, namely a description or design representing something else. In the [OED]() there's a citation dating from 1578 of a description or model of the world according to the doctrine of Ptolemy, not to mention references to architectural models also dating from the 16th c. The model replicates the relationships of the elements of the solar system, building, ship, etc., which connection is mentioned here. $\endgroup$ – Michael E2 Nov 11 '18 at 23:01
2
$\begingroup$

The first appearance of the term “model” as name for an interpretation that satisfies a set of formulas (or theory) is von Neumann's Eine Axiomatisierung der Mengenlehre (1925), §4. MODELS OF SET THEORY.

It seems that the new term owes its success to Hermann Weyl’s Philosophy of Mathematics and Natural Science (1st German ed., 1927), page 20 :

An axiom system must under all circumstances be free from contradictions, in which case it is called consistent [...]. Not indispensable but desirable is the independence of the individual axioms of an axiom system.

There are three methods at one's disposal of reaching this goal [to establish the independence of a proposition $a$ on other propositions $A$ (an axiom system)].

(2) The construction of a model. Objects and relations are exhibited which, upon suitable naming, satisfy all of the propositions $A$, and yet fail to satisfy $a$. This method has been the most successful so far invented. [...]

Klein was the first to offer a Euclidean model for non-Euclidean geometry; the objects of Euclidean geometry itself, upon an assignment of names differing from the customary one, satisfy the non-Euclidean axioms.

More than anybody else has Hilbert, through the ingenious construction of suitable arithmetical models, contributed to the clarification of the logical relations that connect the various parts of the geometrical system of axioms.

We can find the term used by Alfred Tarski in an address on the foundations of the geometry of solids given to the First Polish Mathematical Congress, held in Lwow in 1927. A summary of the address appeared in French under the title ‘Les fondements de la géométrie des corps’, 1927.


Thus the connection with "representation" is due to the technique of interpreting a geometrical system into a different one.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

I expect "model" is used in model theory imitating previous uses in mathematics. Such as for non-euclidean geometry. (the Klein model, the Poincaré disk model, the Poincaré half-plane model, the Lorentz model.) In the 19th century, the fact that hyperbolic geometry is consistent was shown by exhibiting a model for it inside Euclidean geometry, which was considered to be clearly consistent.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.