Skip to main content

Questions tagged [relativity-theory]

For questions regarding either the special or general theories of relativity.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
2 votes
1 answer
66 views

Why is the Bondi-Van der Burg-Metzner-Sachs group often called only Bondi-Metzner-Sachs group?

In general relativity, the Bondi-Van der Burg-Metzner-Sachs (BMS) group is the group of symmetries of future null infinity. To the best of my knowledge, it originated in the works of Bondi, Van der ...
Níckolas Alves's user avatar
0 votes
1 answer
146 views

Would they have known you can't go faster than light in 1790 [duplicate]

I came across this short: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/LjBaPxutpQo where Brian Cox says the idea of black holes dates back to 1790. It stemmed according to it from escape velocity and that you could ...
Rohit Pandey's user avatar
2 votes
1 answer
206 views

What was the reason Einstein included reflection from a moving mirror in his relativity paper?

Einstein, in his 1905 relativity paper Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies, allocates a section to the issue of reflection of light from a moving mirror and derives three formulas (angle, frequency, ...
Maesumi's user avatar
  • 133
5 votes
0 answers
66 views

Schwarzschild's artificial planet

In a 1963 article by Robert Dicke ("The observational basis of general relativity"), there is a reference to a concept for a gravitational experimental device in the form of a big ball ...
Slereah's user avatar
  • 895
1 vote
0 answers
131 views

Could Newton have come up with General Relativity? [closed]

I was reading this question. There I read somewhere that he would have discovered modern physics if he had studied electromagnetism and nuclear physics. It was most likely in jest. But I ask How much ...
Alfredo's user avatar
  • 11
0 votes
0 answers
54 views

The Langevin twins

When did exactly the Langevin twins occur in relativity? My first idea was to simply look up Langevin's original paper (in 1911), but he never mentions them to be twins : our traveller would need ...
Slereah's user avatar
  • 895
1 vote
1 answer
562 views

Did Einstein really explain Relativity using the hot stove/pretty girl analogy and if so why?

I am pretty sure that Albert Einstein explained special relativity by saying in effect, sitting on a hot stove for a minute can seem like an hour; sit with a pretty girl for an hour and it might seem ...
releseabe's user avatar
  • 1,173
9 votes
1 answer
1k views

Where did the popular idea of spacetime come from?

[This question is about popular conceptions and therefore goes into strange directions, don't get too shocked] The notion of spacetime can be traced back to roughly the 18th century where some people ...
Slereah's user avatar
  • 895
6 votes
3 answers
8k views

Why didn't Einstein propose any metric solution to his equations?

I've read about general relativity (GR) recently and something stroke me: Einstein came up with his equations in 1915, linking the metric of spacetime to the distribution of energy (more exactly, to ...
Weier's user avatar
  • 379
4 votes
0 answers
135 views

What are some outdated concepts in general relativity?

Inspired by outdated concepts in special relativity such as When and why did the concept of relativistic mass become outdated? and Special relativity and imaginary coefficient of the time coordinate, ...
Mauricio's user avatar
  • 3,937
22 votes
3 answers
4k views

What is the origin of the rubber sheet analogy?

I am trying to track down the first use of the 'bowling ball on a rubber sheet' analogy to explain spacetime curvature in general relativity. I have found a lot of secondary sources that give ...
Kerida's user avatar
  • 321
0 votes
0 answers
111 views

Historical origins of the idea that information cannot travel faster than light

Is there a good book or other reference that discusses the historical origins of the principle that not even information can travel faster than the speed of light? In my understanding the main reason ...
Inzinity's user avatar
  • 109
4 votes
3 answers
293 views

Before Einstein did people realize about a falling man not feeling weight?

I understand that Einstein was able to draw remarkable conclusions and was set on the path of General relativity when he realized that a falling observer not feeling his own weight. But is it believed ...
releseabe's user avatar
  • 1,173
2 votes
1 answer
151 views

Weyl's gauge theory and railroad tracks

There is a claim I occasionally read that the origin of the word "gauge" refers to a track gauge used in railroad tracks (the distance between two rails). It's a claim I have seen here, here,...
Slereah's user avatar
  • 895
1 vote
1 answer
127 views

Paradigms in Newtonian physics around 1900

I am thinking about the change from Newtonian mechanics to quantum physics and relativity. I note that we have accepted the words "ultraviolet catastrophe" in connection with the situation ...
Mikael Jensen's user avatar
3 votes
1 answer
258 views

Did Einstein believe the laws of physics would be replaced by mathematical identities?

I'm sure this wasn't his intention at the outset, but here's my understanding of the history of GR so you can see where I'm coming from: The Einstein-Grossmann "Entwurf" version of the ...
Adam Herbst's user avatar
2 votes
0 answers
584 views

What did Einstein say about the Dirac equation?

The wiki article on Dirac quotes Einstein as saying of Dirac I have trouble with Dirac. This balancing on the dizzying path between genius and madness is awful. and I don't understand Dirac at all. ...
Adam Herbst's user avatar
1 vote
1 answer
221 views

Interviews / Conversations with Einstein

I'm searching interviews and/or conversations (in English) with Einstein as text. Is there something available? In particular physics (e.g. theory of relativity) would be interesting but also other (e....
BlackHawk's user avatar
  • 113
1 vote
0 answers
68 views

Origin of the terminology "Einstein frame" and "Jordan frame"

Consider a classical scalar-tensor theory (I'm following this paper) \begin{equation} S=\int d^4x\sqrt{-g}\left( \frac{1}{2\kappa^2}\mathcal{A}\left(\Phi\right)R -\frac{1}{2}\mathcal{...
physics_researcher's user avatar
1 vote
1 answer
129 views

Is there history of all the blind alleys Einstein followed between 1905 and 1915 in formulating General Relativity?

My impression is that the equivalence of the force experienced in an accelerating elevator to the force experienced as a result of gravity is what inspired Einstein to quantify gravity in terms of the ...
aquagremlin's user avatar
1 vote
0 answers
85 views

Hilbert's criticism on the first version of Einstein's field equations

Crossposted at Physics Stack Exchange I have read once that Hilbert had some reservations regarding the first form of the field equations $$ R_{\mu\nu} = k T_{\mu\nu} $$ because it was not possible ...
Alucard's user avatar
  • 111
4 votes
0 answers
127 views

References for Laplace's question regarding Newtonian Gravity

In this lecture by Prof. Frederic Schuller @ 17:49 , it is said that Laplace asked a question if force could be seen equally as curvature of the underlying space which the particle moves in. However, ...
Babu's user avatar
  • 483
1 vote
0 answers
174 views

Is Edmund Whittaker claim that Hilbert proved General Relativity days before Einstein valid?

Are the claims of Sir Edmund Whittaker regarding David Hilbert's derivation of the general relativity theory predated that of Einstein by five days? This Wikipedia article that I found contains the ...
user16873's user avatar
2 votes
1 answer
389 views

How did they know that the space could expand?

The theory of general relativity was formulated around 1915 which could be summed up in words of John Wheeler, "Space-time tells matter how to move; matter tells space-time how to curve". At ...
PG1995's user avatar
  • 387
4 votes
0 answers
712 views

James M. Bardeen's missing talk

Back in 1968, James M. Bardeen (son of John Bardeen) gave a talk at the GR5 (5th international conference on gravitation and the theory of relativity), in which he presented a slight modification of ...
Ivica Smolić's user avatar
1 vote
1 answer
148 views

Physical theories and Mathematics [closed]

I study pure mathematics. In pure mathematics, we begin from some axioms and obtain theorems. I am also interested in studying physics. I have some questions about the relationship between physical ...
S Ali Mousavi's user avatar
10 votes
2 answers
3k views

Did a Chinese astronomical text conduct the "Galileo's Ship" thought experiment around the 2nd century BCE?

A math and physics magazine I was browsing through contains the quotation The Earth is moving constantly, but people do not know it; like the crew in an enclosed ship, they do not notice it. The ...
Mark Eichenlaub's user avatar
3 votes
1 answer
367 views

What was Einstein's first publication of the final form of general relativity?

What was Einstein's first published exposition of his final form of general relativity, be it a scientific article or a book? I've been googling the answer for hours now, with no luck, really. The ...
Sasha's user avatar
  • 171
13 votes
2 answers
2k views

Who was the first to hypothesise that gravity from one mass causes the spacetime around another mass to curve?

Was it Einstein? Or was there someone before him to hypothesise this?
user avatar
2 votes
0 answers
51 views

How did Mach's view on spacetime differ from Einstein's?

We can read in Wikipedia: Mach's principle, in cosmology, hypothesis that the inertial forces experienced by a body in nonuniform motion are determined by the quantity and distribution of matter in ...
Deschele Schilder's user avatar
2 votes
1 answer
216 views

Who named Black Hole?

A black hole is a compact region of spacetime where gravity is so strong that nothing, even light, can escape from its event horizon, and, interestingly, Einstein didn't accept this viewpoint. Now, I'...
Ancient Friend's user avatar
0 votes
0 answers
139 views

Gravity's Rainbow: An accidental nominal similarity in science and literature?

There is an interesting extension of Einstein's Special Relativity, known as Doubly Special Relativity (presented after 2002) in which there is not only an observer-independent maximum velocity (i.e., ...
Ancient Friend's user avatar
1 vote
0 answers
81 views

Maxwell equations and aether

Were Maxwells equations (in their usual common form) assumed to be valid only in ether frame,in the past? If someone would ask them "In what frame are you writing these equations " ,what ...
Kashmiri's user avatar
  • 183
5 votes
1 answer
461 views

What is the history of adding the Clock Hypothesis to Special Relativity?

As far as I understand, Einstein’s original formulation of Special Relativity did not include the Clock Hypothesis, though it was implicitly assumed. The modern formulation of SR adds a formal ...
nwr's user avatar
  • 6,909
3 votes
1 answer
100 views

Books about the development/history of gravitational theory

I am looking for a book about the history of gravitational theory. It should obviously include discussions of Newton, Einstein, and their theories, and hopefully it would include the work of other ...
Mathew Mehrian's user avatar
29 votes
3 answers
8k views

Why did no one else, except Einstein, work on developing General Relativity between 1905-1915?

Einstein dedicated his time between 1905-1915 to develop general relativity (GR). It seems strange to me that no other physicists attempted to tackle this problem in this ten-year period. After all, ...
Omar Nagib's user avatar
9 votes
1 answer
356 views

Is Hermann Weyl's book “Space, Time, Matter” (1923) on General Relativity still relevant?

I really liked Hermann Weyl's mathematical books and would like to get accustomed to general relativity from his perspective, but wonder if it's still relevant after almost 100 (!) years? Can this ...
Slaus's user avatar
  • 191
1 vote
0 answers
86 views

Did Arthur Schuster anticipate the equivalence between matter and energy in his speculations about antimatter?

Here Schuster apparently discussed matter and antimatter annihilating each other. Had anyone suggested before this that matter could be transformed into energy? (If indeed that is what is implied by ...
releseabe's user avatar
  • 1,173
3 votes
0 answers
108 views

Different versions of mass during early years of special relativity

My question is basically about four different versions of mass from the early years of special relativity when the concept of relativistic mass was acceptable. I'd appreciate it if you try to keep ...
PG1995's user avatar
  • 387
3 votes
2 answers
703 views

Why did energy-momentum relationship have to wait until 1928 to be established?

This web page shows how to derive energy-momentum relationship, $E_{total}^2=p^{2}c^{2}+\left( mc^{2}\right) ^{2}$, given the following equations. Please note that some sources make a distinction ...
PG1995's user avatar
  • 387
6 votes
1 answer
630 views

Einstein: 'SR is a theory of invariants, not relativity' -- source?

It is occasionally remarked that Einstein was unhappy that SR became referred to as a ‘theory of relativity’, when in his eyes it was, much more importantly, a theory of invariants (Invariantentheorie)...
Norman Gray's user avatar
4 votes
1 answer
332 views

Were there doubts that Voigt's time dilation was correct rather than Einstein's?

According to Wikipedia's Voigt transformation: Lorentz did not adopt this transformation, as he found in 1904 that only the Lorentz contraction corresponds to the principle of relativity. Since ...
PG1995's user avatar
  • 387
1 vote
1 answer
289 views

What is a spacetime continuum?

A very common expression I see in pop science is "the spacetime continuum". This expression isn't commonly used in modern discussions of general relativity, but looking at some older papers on the ...
Slereah's user avatar
  • 895
2 votes
0 answers
381 views

First paper introducing the concept of four-vectors

I'm trying to find the first paper in which the concept of four-vectors was introduced. I read "Principle of Relativity" by H. Minkowski but he only presents the notion of metric and invariant space-...
Генивалдо's user avatar
0 votes
0 answers
61 views

Were Christoffel symbols used by Riemann?

The answer to the question would appear to be "no" looking at the transcription of Riemann's 1854 Ueber die Hypothesen, welche der Geometrie zu Grunde liegen lecture. However, Bernhard Riemann (1826-...
Antoni Parellada's user avatar
6 votes
1 answer
135 views

What was the original reason physicists first believed that light must follow a geodesic?

Context: One of the key reasons Einstein first suspected space is curved by mass is due to the falling elevator thought experiment. This experiment implies that mass must curve the path of a light ray....
Rory Cornish's user avatar
3 votes
1 answer
185 views

Einstein praising Sophus Lie

p. 153 of Raúl M. Falcón Ganfornina and Juan Núñez Valdés, “Mathematical Foundations of Santilli Isotopies,” trans. Alan Aversa, Algebras, Groups, and Geometries 32 (2015): 135–308. quotes (but does ...
Geremia's user avatar
  • 5,371
-1 votes
1 answer
87 views

What was the chain of theories that led to relativity? [closed]

Can you briefly sketch the sequence of math theories that were necessary for Einstein to figure out a convincing background for relativity?
user157860's user avatar
23 votes
3 answers
6k views

What was the relationship between Einstein and Minkowski?

I read many Einstein's Biographies, but Minkowski was never mentioned, though his discovery of the union of space and time created the basis for GR. Minkowski was Einstein's teacher of mathematics ...
Realist753's user avatar
3 votes
1 answer
315 views

Is it true Einstein doubted relativity near the end of his life?

Heard he wrote a bunch of rambling thoughts near the end of his life and doubted his own theory of relativity...it was in Einstein: His Life and Universe by Walter Isaacson
bill's user avatar
  • 31